The company was started in the year 1976 by the Virani family. First they used to supply the wafers at Astron cinema in Rajkot. After getting success they set up a semi automatic plant which increased its sales. The company is producing 2 types of products i. e. wafers and namkeen.
Balaji Wafers Private Limited is a medium scale company producing wafers and namkeens. The company has a good brand name in Gujarat, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Goa and Rajasthan. It has 90% market share of wafers and 70%market share of namkeens in Gujarat.
The unit is located at Vajdi, Kalawad road, Rajkot. The company has another plant at Valsad.
PRODUCTION DEPARTMENT
PRODUCTION TECHNOLOGY:
In a fully automatic plant like Balaji all the aspects of manufacturing are carried on by computers, operated by few men. Balaji Wafers Private Limited has fully automatic plant with latest machineries. Benefits of economies of scale, standardised products, speedy production and fewer accidents are achieved.
PRODUCTION PROCESS:
The important aspect of any company is its production process In BALAJI WAFERS PVT. LTD., production process is a well – planned process. In contains all that important stages, which is required to make a product well, accepted in the market. Layout is as follows:
Raw material–washing–peeling–inspection–cutting–washing–frying–inspection–adding spices–dispatch
QUALITY CONTROL:
Quality control department of BALAJI WAFERS checks the quality of the goods with the help of equipments. This department checks the quality of raw material and finished products. Not only this, it also checked the quality of the product at each stage of the production.
INVENTORY MANAGEMENT:
The company has a systematic inventory control. For inventory, it uses First In First Out (FIFO) method. They dispatch the finish products as soon as they are produced. Company does not hold inventory for more than 2 days including raw material and finish products.
PERSONNEL DEPARTMENT
SELECTION AND RECRUITMENT:
In BALAJI WAFERS, they recruit staff member through advertisement in highly circulated news paper. They are not using any employment exchange or employment agencies for recruitment. Selection committee member select candidates by interview. After the candidate is selected, the company gives him appointment letter that when he has to join the company.
WAGES AND SALARY:
The remuneration is paid to each and every worker not on the monthly basis but on daily basis. On the other hand salaries to other staff members are paid monthly. These wages and salaries are according to government norms. Employee also receives bonus and gifts on special occasion or at festivals.
PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL SYSTEM:
Performance Appraisal is a process of evaluating an employee’s performance of a job in terms of its results. In ‘ Balaji Wafers Pvt. Ltd.’ the supervisor sees the employees ability that they work properly and efficiently, whether he understands, his responsibilities or not, how his behaviour towards his colleague etc.
TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT:
The company gives continues training to new employee but they don’t give training to old employee. Training is given to the employee to make them aware as how to operate machines, how to do the work very effectively and in given time limit, etc. The main aim of training is to develop leadership quality and responsibility, and work can be carried out in most efficient manner and also very smoothly.
MARKETING DEPARTMENT
PRODUCT POLICY:
The product policy and strategy is the cornerstone of marketing mix. In Balaji Wafers Pvt. Ltd. following steps are followed in product planning.
Market price and sale price
Demand of particular commodity
Cost of production
Necessity and aim of company
PRICING POLICY:
The company’s pricing policy is cost + profit. Whatever expenses have incurred during the manufacturing of the product is considered plus profit is also included. Competitor’s prices are also considered. Through this they try to reduce their cost of production.
DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL:
The company has very strong distribution channel. It has distributor named “ Kataria” that ensures to supply fresh product in any corner of Gujarat 24 hours. Hence the availability of Balaji’s product is very large.
COMPETITOR:
As Balaji Wafers Pvt. Ltd. has very wide marketing area it is but obvious that it will also have some competitors in this field. The main competitors are as follows.
Main competitors:-
Lays, Atop, Kukure, Gopal Namkeen, Uncle chips, Haldirams Namkeen
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK OF RESEARCH
BACKGROUND OF THE TOPIC
Definition of Retailer:
One who sells goods and commodities directly to the consumers. These items are purchased from the manufacturer or wholesaler and sells to the end user at the market price. He is also known as merchant.
Retailing consists of the sales of goods or merchandise from the fixed location in small or individual lots for direct consumption by the purchaser. There are no restriction on how and where the retailer start his business. He has full freedom of doing the business he wants to do which is a biggest advantage. Retailing includes all the activities involved in selling goods and services directly to final consumers for personal, non-business use.
The purpose of conducting the retail survey is to determine the relationship with the retailers. Knowledge of retailer satisfaction and attitudes about an organization’s business will greatly enhance its opportunity to make better business decisions. The organisation will try to make better relations with them by fulfilling their expectations
PROBLEM STATEMENT:
It is extremely crucial to know the retailer satisfaction level towards the products of Balaji Wafers Private Limited. We need to know that how many retailers sell the product of Balaji? Which other brand product do they sell? Are they satisfied with the distribution system? Are dealers providing services which they need? Do they want any promotion efforts?
Through the analysis, interpretation and findings from this study these issues can be solved.
RATIONALE OF THE STUDY
Organisation is made up of people and without people organisation does not exists. The resources by themselves cannot fulfil the objectives of the organisation. The resources need to unite into the team.
The main need of the study is to determine the impact of retailers’ satisfaction at every place in marketing management. If the retailers are satisfied with services of the firm they can provide useful information to the company and act as a bridge between end users and manufacturer.
Thus we can say that the research on retailers’ satisfaction will prove beneficial to the Balaji Wafers Private Limited. This study will give information about the expectations of the retailers and fulfil those requirements. All this will lead to a great success for the company.
REVIEW OF EXISTING LITERATURE
(A) Commitment-trust theory of Relationship Marketing
Findings: (1) Relationship marketing means establishing, developing, and maintaining successful relations with retailers and dealers. (2) It plays a major role in marketing theory and practice. The authors find out that successful relationship marketing requires relationship commitment and trust; and the model of commitment and trust is a key mediating variables. Robert M. Morgan and Shelby D. Hunt (July-1994) Publisher: American Marketing Association
(B) Market orientation, trust and satisfaction in dyadic relationship: a manufacturer-retailer analysis
Findings: (1) It studies the relationship between manufacturer’s behaviour and the distributors’ and retailers’ trust and satisfaction with it. It analysis the effect of trust their satisfaction level. (2) Three alternative models of relationships between trust and satisfaction are compared. (3) The article presents the study of Spanish ceramic industry. It shows that the effect of trust on satisfaction depends on which dimension is considered. Enrique Bigne and Andreau Blesa (2003) Publisher: MCB UP Ltd
(C) Determinants of supplier-retailer collaboration
Findings: (1) This study aims to understand the factors influencing supplier-retailer collaborations. (2) A comprehensive supplier-retailer relationship model is developed: supplier-retailer business relationship affects long-term orientation; supplier-retailer business relationship affects supply chain architecture; long-term orientation affects supply chain architecture; supply chain architecture affects the level of supplier-retailer collaboration; and supplier-retailer collaboration enhances supplier-retailer performance. Chwen Sheu and Bongsug Chae (2006) Publisher: Emerald Group Publishing Limited
[D] Consumer shopping value, satisfaction and loyalty in discount retailing
Findings: (1) Few researchers have conducted comprehensive examinations of the relationships between consumer shopping value, satisfaction and loyalty in retailing. (2)Further, the majority of extant research has been limited to upscale retail sectors where the role of the salesperson is crucial and long-term relationships are common. (3)In order to extend the findings of previous research to additional retail sectors, the current study investigates the complex interrelationships between utilitarian and hedonic shopping value and important retail outcomes for discount retailers. Jason M. Carpenter (September-2008)
HYPOTHESIS
H0: The research proves that retailers are satisfied
H1: The research proves that retailers are not satisfied
OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
The objectives of the retailer survey are as follows:
To study current scenario of Wafer market and Namkeen market
To find out the services provided by dealers
To know about timely delivery of goods by dealers
To know the satisfaction level of the retailers
To find out the scope of new product
To find out awareness of the products
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
SCOPE AND POPULATION
Scope of the study shows the area and fields covered under the study. In my research work I had covered all the retail outlets of the Rajkot City. It includes the following:
General Stores
Dairy Farm
Pan Shops
Grocery Shops
Population of the study means the number respondents approached in the research work. I had approached 200 retail outlets for filling up the questionnaires. The areas covered are as follows:
Area
No. of Retailers
University road
32
Raiya road
41
Kalawad road
27
Sadhu vasvani road
18
Laxmi nagar road
14
Yagnik road
8
Amin marg
15
Nirmala convent road
10
Mavdi road
8
150 feet ring road
12
Other
15
SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY
This study will be significant in promoting good work environment in the workplace and motivation of its retailers. This study will also be beneficial to the students and instructors in retail management. It will be also helpful to the retail management, marketing management and overall company’s objectives and strategies.
It will also serve as future reference for researchers on the subject of marketing and brand development. And importantly, this research will educate clients in deciding on whether a company is really fulfilling its responsibility to the retailers and other intermediaries or not.
DATA COLLECTION METHOD
There are two types of data:
Primary Data
Secondary Data
In my research work I had used only primary data. Primary data is to be collected to know the retailers’ preferences and belief. A combination of Questionnaire techniques and discussions with the respondents are used to collect the required Primary data. Findings of the primary data focus on the retailers of the Balaji Wafers. Primary data gives higher accuracy and facts, which is very helpful for any research.
I had collected data from the grocery shops, dairy farm, pan shops and general stores with the help of questionnaires.
SAMPLING DESIGN
This Research is more related to descriptive type because the retailer’s knowledge, beliefs and satisfaction of services can be judge through this type of research.
No particular statistical technique was used to determine sample size for the research work. Large samples give more reliable results than small samples. So I decided to collect the data from the 200 respondents.
Sampling procedure:
For the survey of the retailers the responses had recorded by giving the questionnaire to them and provide them all the information about the purpose so that they can give true information.
In this study of retailers, the sample size is 200 and the type of sampling is quota sampling because out of 200 retailers each retail shops are taken who are selling the products of Balaji into equal proportion which is given below:
General stores
Pan Shops
Grocery Shops
Dairy Farm
TOOLS AND TECHNIQUES
Data Collection tool:
For the descriptive types of research the tools for collecting the data is questionnaire method. The questionnaire includes both types of questions i. e. close ended and open ended questions. In my questionnaire I had used both types of questions.
Data Analysis Tool:
The data collected from the sample by various method need to be analysed. There are various tools and techniques for research study which helps in analysing and interpreting the data collected I had used the Spreadsheet for analysis and interpretation of the data collected from the questionnaire. Spreadsheets are widely used because they are relatively easy to learn, and can help the user do quick and simple data analysis.
LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
Following are the limitations of the research study:
The research is done only in limited area.
Some retailers provide biased information.
It is difficult to predict the satisfaction level of Retailers because there are many retail outlets in Rajkot.
Some retailers has given incomplete information.
Some respondents refused to fill up the questionnaire.
DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION
The data collected through the questionnaire are scanned and analyzed. The analysis and interpretation of data is very important in any research work. After analysis and interpretation the findings and recommendations can be provided to the company. Therefore it has a greater importance in the whole study.
Let us analyze and interpret one by one data.
Q-1: Are you selling Balaji’s Product?
Interpretation:
From 200 retailers, 06 are not selling Balaji product. The reasons are as follows:
Few retail shops are remotely located, so a dealer is not able to provide necessary services.
The other reason is that some retailers have less requirement so sales executives don’t visit them.
Dealer has very large area to cover. So sometimes it is difficult to satisfy all the retailers.
Q-2: Which products are being sold at your retail outlet?
According to the retailers most of the customers prefer the following products which are sold in large quantity from their shop.
Potato masala wafers
Chat Chaska wafers
Simply Salted wafers
Tomato wafers
Banana masala wafers
Banana mari wafers
Faradi Chevdo
Aloo Sev
Chataka Pataka (masala)
Wheelos
Products which are sold not very frequently are:
Masala peas
Shing bhujia
Masala shing
Ratlami Sev
Gathiya
Khatta mitha mix
Tikha mitha mix
Chataka pataka (tangy tomato)
Products which sold very less are:
Lemon chatka
Chinese chatka
Khakhras
These products are sold very less because people are not aware about it. Another reason is that the retailers are not having these products in their stock as they are also not informed about it.
Q-3: Are you satisfied with the distribution system of “ Balaji”?
Interpretation:
All the retailers are satisfied with the distribution system as the whole distribution system is managed by “ Kataria”. Within 24 hours it supplies the product of Balaji at any corner in Gujarat.
Q-4: Does the dealer give necessary services?
Interpretation:
Retailers are satisfied with the services from the dealers. This shows that Balaji Wafers has strong relations with all its channel intermediaries.
Q-5: How many times in a week dealer gives you services?
Interpretation:
The above chart shows that 91% of retailer gets 2 times service from the retailer. This is because there is large consumption of Balaji products and as such it is necessary to get 2 times deliveries in a week.
Q-6: Did you face delay in receiving the products of “ Balaji”?
Proportion test:
p = 0. 90, q = 0. 10 and n = 200
S. E. = pq/n = 0. 021
Limit = [p – 3(S. E.)]*100 to [p + 3(S. E)]*100
= 83. 70% to 96. 30%
Interpretation:
The above chart shows that only 10. 21% of retailer are dissatisfied and are getting delay in receiving the products as they are located in remote areas.
Q-7: Do you provide the information to the company about the loyal consumers and their purchases?
Proportion test:
p = 0. 39, q = 0. 61 and n = 200
S. E. = pq/n = 0. 034
Limit = [p – 3(S. E.)]*100 to [p + 3(S. E)]*100
= 28. 80% to 49. 20%
Interpretation:
As retailers are in face to face contact with the customers they can provide such valuable information. 38. 89% of retailers provide the information about loyal customers.
Q-8: Are you selling other then the products of “ Balaji”?
Proportion test:
p = 0. 58, q = 0. 42 and n = 200
S. E. = pq/n = 0. 035
Limit = [p – 3(S. E.)]*100 to [p + 3(S. E)]*100
= 47. 50% to 68. 50%
Interpretation:
If yes, then other brands are:
Lays, Uncle Chips, Gopal Namkeen, Parle, Atop, Real, Aliva, Bingo, Haldirams Namkeen, Everest and Kurkure.
The retailers sell other brands as they want to provide different type of variety of product to the customers in order to increase their earnings.
Q-9: Do you expect any promotion efforts from the company?
Proportion test:
p = 0. 63, q = 0. 37 and n = 200
S. E. = pq/n = 0. 034
Limit = [p – 3(S. E.)]*100 to [p + 3(S. E)]*100
= 52. 80% to 73. 20%
Interpretation:
The above chart shows that 36. 88% of retailers need promotion benefits. They want trade discount, certain percentage of commission, stand for keeping the products at display and benefits during festivals.
Q-10: People accept “ Balaji’s” product according to which criteria?
Interpretation:
The above chart shows that majority of people accept the product due to taste and availability. Almost 35. 88% is attracted by taste and 27. 77% is attracted by availability. Thus we can say that taste is the main strength for the company.
Q-11: Do you think Balaji is competitive enough with other available products?
Interpretation:
All the retailer believe that Balaji is competitive enough. The company is having almost 90% market share of wafers and 70% of namkeens. This shows that it has ability to stand in completion.
Q-12: Should Balaji introduce new product in market?
Proportion test:
p = 0. 34, q = 0. 66 and n = 200
S. E. = pq/n = 0. 033
Limit = [p – 3(S. E.)]*100 to [p + 3(S. E)]*100
= 24. 10% to 43. 90%
Interpretation:
The above chart shows that 33. 59% of retailer says that Balaji should introduce new product as customer choices and preferences are changing very rapidly. Hence company must try to widen its offerings so that customer will not change the brand.
Q-13: What suggestion would you like to give to company?
Following suggestions are given by the retailers:
Replacement of the product
Introduce different flavors of Wheelos
Shortage of products during festivals
Increase the quantity of wafers
Unaware about new product such as lemon chatka, Chinese chatka and khakhras
SUMMARY
It was a nice experience to conduct the research study of retailer satisfaction. From the study I came to know that the company has a strong distribution network. There are good relations with the distributor and dealers.
The main reason for the better availability of Balaji’s product is because of the services of its distributor “ Kataria”. Its services are highly efficient as it could supply the product within 24 hours in any corner of the Gujarat. So, better availability can be the competitive advantage for the company.
The study shows that the retailers are satisfied with the company. Therefore we accept the null hypothesis as the research proves that retailers are satisfied.
So, I conclude that the company is efficient and effective in its business and is having a good brand name.
FINDINGS
Following are the findings of my research work:
According to the retailer Balaji is competitive enough
Retailers have complaint about fewer profit margin
Retailers are unaware about certain products such as Lemon chatka, Chinese chatka and Khakhras
Customers are also unaware of these products so the sales is also less
There is shortage of products during festivals because of fluctuation in supply
Retailers also need stand for the display of the Balaji products
RECOMMENDATIONS
I would like to give following recommendations to the company:
The company should advertise about the new products to make awareness to the retailer and consumers
The company must increase the profit margin of the retailers in order to satisfy them
Balaji Wafers should give the stands free of cost to the retailer to keep their products in the shop
The company must do some promotional efforts for the retailer by giving discount
Balaji Wafers should increase the quantity of wafers
There must be replacement of product as most of the retailer has given suggestions
The company should increase the supply of aloo sev and masala shing
Balaji Wafers can introduce new flavours in Wheelos