Essay, 7 pages (1900 words)

‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay

Assignment 2


English 115

English 115

Assignment 2

‘ Be Like a Comet, my Sun’

“ And then I stole all courtesy from heaven, And dressed myself in such

humility, That I did pluck allegiance from men’s hearts, Loud shouts and

salutations from their mouths, Even in the presence of their crowned King.

Thus did I keep my person fresh and new,..” (1 Henry IV 3. 2. 50-54 King

Henry) This scene between Hal and his father, leaves the audience in no

doubt as to the King’s attitude concerning his son’s actions. King Henry is

angry because his son is not in council therefore placing himself far away

from the court. As any father would naturally react, he is upset as he is

concerned for his son and more pertinent to this essay, his son’s future.

The King feels that the court and the masses will now have low expectations

of him as a result of his association with the commoners. Henry IV

describes himself as somebody who made something of himself from nothing

using adjectives such as “ stole” “ plucked” and “ dressed”. Unlike Hal who

seems to have had everything made easy for him in life and in his father’s

eyes he is throwing it away. He talks to his son about assuming a role. A

role which involves remaining aloof in order to create a certain mystique,

yet at the same time Henry IV talks of dressing himself in humility. In

other words, the King means the ability to act a certain way and disguise

his true colors. This is intriguing to note as in ‘ Henry V’, Hal takes his

father’s advice literally and actually dresses as one of the soldiers.

Also, early in the first play, during Hal’s first soliloquy, Hal arguably

shows himself to more like his father than the King is aware. The young

prince compares himself to the sun and his common companions to the clouds

that sometimes form a veil over the sun when being viewed from the Earth.

This implies that he is something of high and powerful stature and that

anything that may seem to detract from that permanently is merely a

temporary distraction, as he when he so wished could tear down those veils

to reveal the brightest star of them all.

Indeed, the most noticeable ‘ change’ in Harry is when he becomes King

Henry V. It seems that the new King is eager to throw off his delinquent

reputation and prove himself as an astute leader. However, as previously

mentioned, it could be argued that this notoriety for being a renegade was

fabricated by the young prince in order to emphasize his ascendancy as even

more ‘ wonderful’, an adjective which his father once used in an analogy

about a comet when talking about himself. “ But, like a comet, I was

wondered at.”(1 Henry IV 3. 2. 47)

When considering Henry V true feelings and his relationship with his

subjects it would be naive to omit the valuable insight that can be

ascertained from ‘ 1 Henry IV’ and Hal in his formative years. Was he

playing a role in 1 Henry IV ? Is he playing a role in Henry V or has his

experience taught him anything? It certainly seems that he has many roles

throughout the two plays in much the same way as any human fulfills certain

roles in their lifetime. The soliloquies perhaps give us a true glimpse of

his character’s psyche. However, just using his words in order to pass

judgment would be mere speculation. In the case of this enigmatic figure,

it would seem far more valuable to attempt to ascertain his true feelings

from his words and actions during integral parts of the plays.

It may be fair to assume that Shakespeare agrees as it is interesting

to note that whereas we get Hal’s first soliloquy in Henry IV Part 1 within

the first act, Shakespeare only gives us a glimpse into King Henry’s inner

thoughts late in the play . The relatively new King mentions his lasting

concern regarding the theft of the throne by his father. In ‘ Henry IV’,

his father seems to want Hal to come to terms with what it is to be part of

a family line. However, Hal certainly seems to have some difficulty in

seeing his legitimate claim to the throne as virtuous since his father

stole it. He is not from a royal blood line. He admits to himself that he

would rather be a slave who has no responsibilities(Henry V. Act IV. i. 248-

250) When considering these kinds of comments which Henry V makes when

lamenting the loneliness and responsibilities of his position as ruler, it

could be argued that in Henry IV perhaps Hal knew of his responsibilities

that were about to become him and his actions reflected that like a last

holiday before the end of summer for example.

Henry presents us with the idea that his motivation for his actions as

king are not power, lust or arrogance, but simply a crushing sense of

responsibility to preserve stability and order for his subjects. Obviously,

this can be questioned due to the position of power that Henry V has found

himself in. It can be stated without much argument that he abandoned his

‘ friends’ from the Boar’s Head the moment they became obsolete. His

execution of traitors and his ‘ friends’ is done with a clinical feel and at

the very least his reasons for invading France are ambiguous. It is

interesting to note the new King’s response when one of the soldiers

questions the Kings motives for invading France. Henry does not consider

the question of responsibility for what William describes as “ if the cause

not be good, then the King himself has a heavy reckoning to make……. I

am afeard there are few die well that die in a battle.” (Henry V. IV. i. 128-

135) Instead, he chooses to argue the religious side of the argument as

opposed to William’s initial statement.

This could possibly connote the idea of Hal being fickle, a notion

which could easily be put forward but possibly somewhat naively. In very

much the same way as Malvolio of Shakespeare’s ‘ Twelfth Night’ an audience

may at times sympathize with the protagonist of this play whilst conceding

that he has his faults. At the end of ‘ Twelfth Night’ when Malvolio is

subject to some rather cruel and unusual torture at the hands of Maria and

Sir Toby, he remains true to himself and never for an instant believes that

he could be insane. In the same way King Henry never truly loses his

association with the commoners. He may distance himself from the friends he

had at the Boars Head but some dialogue from Henry IV left us wondering

whether he was such good friends with the so called ‘ crew of rascals’.

Therefore, it is certain to say that Hal, arguably more than any other King

in any other play knows how to interact with common people most probably as

a result of his experiences in his formative years at the Tavern. Further

evidence to disprove the notion of Hal being fickle is evident in his

discussion with the soldiers. Previously, he has walked among them as King

and proclaimed that he was their brother. However, during this discussion,

there is no reason for pretence as the soldiers have no idea as to his true

identity. Whilst arguing with William, the cloaked King refuses to change

his opinion and is willing to fight as a result of his convictions.

Throughout the two plays Henry/Hal ‘ disguises’ himself on a number of

occasions. His father talks of him about cloaking (acting) and Henry

literally heeds his advice in ‘ Henry V Act IV’. This scene is of most

intrigue when attempting to judge Hal. He is obviously assuming a role when

disguised in a common cloak but whether any more so than the rest of the

time is extremely debatable. For example, long before this in ‘ 1 Henry IV’,

Hal disguises himself as a commoner. For much of this play, Hal cloaks

himself in common company .

This use of disguise, obviously brings about negative connotations of

concealment. One point that should be stated is that it is easier to ‘ hide’

in taverns and in the bottom of a pint of ale than to stand up and be

counted and be responsible for being the heir to the throne and the next

ruler of these very people which he chooses to surround himself with now.

Only truly great men can keep company with the men that they will rule over

as a huge amount of respect has to be given over with grace by the

subjects. On the other hand, it is easier for a ruler to remain aloof and

wondered at like a comet as it helps add to the mystique that one human

being, a king, is actually not like another, a subject. Hal is not one or

the other. That is to say he is not a royal or a commoner. It is important

to note that Shakespeare managed to give us glimpses of the ‘ real’

character. For example, his use of soliloquies and language gives us more

than a look at the character of the role he was supposed to fulfill within

the play, for example the ‘ Prince of Wales’.

Hal’s father spoke to him about a comet. He used the analogy as a

comet is something which is infrequent and as a consequence becomes

something to be wondered at . Presumably, the old king wanted his son to be

more than just a star. This would be for the reason that any man can simply

lift his eyes toward the night sky and will be able to see them as he

pleases. It is fair to argue that Hal is more than a star. He is enigmatic

to the point of wonder. His father wanted him to be a comet, however it is

clear that Hal aspires to be much more than that. He draws comparisons

between himself and the sun, the brightest and most powerful star of them


Hal can be regal , he can also be as common as the next man. If a

director was to cast this role he would have to find an intelligent man

with a lot of depth who can appear no different to the average man.

However, while he appears no different, one cannot tell whether he is just

the same. Hal has the rare ability to set himself apart from the crowd.

That’s what makes him who he is . Not an easy job for a casting director!

In conclusion, one can only offer an honest appraisal from their own

perspective as to what Hal/Henry V’s true feelings are about his men. In

times in his life he has become friends with so-called ‘ common men’,

therefore at times he likes them. At times he has not. At times he has been

genuinely hurt by them, an example of which would be when he speaks to the

traitors who attempted to take his life. Hal and Henry V cares about his

fellow man and he can act as though he cares about his fellow man.

Therefore, in this respect, he is their brother because which man has not

had mixed feelings and emotions about his fellow man at different stages in

their life. Ultimately he is hedonistic prince and an effective ruler.

Ultimately he is a man.

Thank's for Your Vote!
‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay. Page 1
‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay. Page 2
‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay. Page 3
‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay. Page 4
‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay. Page 5
‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay. Page 6
‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay. Page 7
‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay. Page 8
‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay. Page 9

This work, titled "‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay" was written and willingly shared by a fellow student. This sample can be utilized as a research and reference resource to aid in the writing of your own work. Any use of the work that does not include an appropriate citation is banned.

If you are the owner of this work and don’t want it to be published on AssignBuster, request its removal.

Request Removal
Cite this Essay


AssignBuster. (2022) '‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay'. 22 November.


AssignBuster. (2022, November 22). ‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay. Retrieved from https://assignbuster.com/be-like-a-comet-my-sun-essay/


AssignBuster. 2022. "‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay." November 22, 2022. https://assignbuster.com/be-like-a-comet-my-sun-essay/.

1. AssignBuster. "‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay." November 22, 2022. https://assignbuster.com/be-like-a-comet-my-sun-essay/.


AssignBuster. "‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay." November 22, 2022. https://assignbuster.com/be-like-a-comet-my-sun-essay/.

Work Cited

"‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay." AssignBuster, 22 Nov. 2022, assignbuster.com/be-like-a-comet-my-sun-essay/.

Get in Touch

Please, let us know if you have any ideas on improving ‘be like a comet, my sun’ essay, or our service. We will be happy to hear what you think: [email protected]